Does Peer Review Need to Change? A Panel on Reporting Standards and Checklists in the Age of AI

StatusVoR
Dublin Core metadata
Alternative title
Authors
Duchowski, Andrew
Stefik, Andreas
Ralph, Paul
Dix, Alan
Krejtz, Krzysztof
Myers, Brad A.
Jorge, Joaquim
Wehbe, Rina R.
Monograph
CHI EA '26: Proceedings of the Extended Abstracts of the 2026 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems
Monograph (alternative title)
Editor
Oliver, Nuria
Shamma, David A.
Candello, Heloisa
Cesar, Pablo
Lopes, Pedro
Artizzu, Valentino
Draxler, Fiona
Lopez, Gustavo
Reinschluessel, Anke V.
Tong, Xin
Date
2026-04-13
Place of publication
Publisher
Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
Journal title
Proceedings of the Extended Abstracts of the 2026 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems
Volume
Pages
1-5
DOI
ISSN
ISBN
979-8-4007-2281-3
eISBN
Series
Series number
ISSN of series
Weblink
Access date
2026-04-13
Remarks
Abstract PL
Abstract EN
Many scientific fields of study use formally established reportingstandards to foster research and experimental design, transparency,replicability, peer review, and student training. Examples includeCONSORT in medicine, the What Works Clearinghouse in educa-tion, JARS in psychology. Such standards yield agreement on studyreporting and evaluation, even if using different methodologies.CHI has not adopted reporting standards. Like other fields, CHI hasseen an increased number of low-quality submissions and reviewsfueled by AI. This panel’s objective is to discuss advantages and bar-riers of adopting reporting standards for SIGCHI. Panelists includerepresentatives with significant experience creating, adopting andoperationalizing reporting standards in adjacent fields: softwareengineering, CS education, and Programming Languages. The panelwill include an overview of the history of reporting standards, a livedemo of a standards-based peer review system, discussions of op-portunities, challenges, limitations for SIGCHI reporting standards,and an interactive discussion between attendees and panelists
Abstract other
Keywords PL
Keywords EN
evidence standards
reporting templates
review checklists
Keywords other
Conference edition name
2026 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems
Conference place
Barcelona
Start date
2026-04-13
Finish date
2026-04-17
Sustainable Development Goals
SDG 8. Decent Work and Economic Growth ,
SDG 5. Gender Equality ,
SDG 4. Quality Education
Exhibition title
Place of exhibition (institution)
Exhibition curator
Organisational Unit
Wydział Psychologii w Warszawie
Instytut Psychologii
URI
https://share.swps.edu.pl/handle/swps/2432
Type
Version
Version of Record
License type
cc-by
Except as otherwise noted, this item is licensed under the Attribution licence | Permitted use of copyrighted works
Funder
Time range from
Time range to
Contact person name
item.page.relation.dataset
Related publication
Related publication
Grant/project name
Grant number
Views
Views0
Acquisition Date20.10.2022
Downloads
Downloads0
Acquisition Date20.10.2022